On philosophy and friendship and on grief for lost friends, translated by r. Aristotle and the philosophy of friendship by lorraine. Taken together, these two points allow aristotle to escape, i think, the postmodern paradoxes about the possibility of altruism posed, for example, by jacques derrida. It considers ideals of intimacy and fusion in the context of claims that such ideals are unrealistic and even dangerous. This book explains the persistence of friendship today in the light of the history of philosophical approaches to the subject. John boswell, christianity, social tolerance, and homosexuality. Its the kind that usually comes up a lot when youre a kid or teenager. Reviewed by gabriel richardson lear, university of chicago from an aristotelian point of view it is tempting to think that friendship can show us something important about moral virtue since it is in this context that. Aristotle, whose writing on friendship still sets the philosophical agenda to this day, found as much 2,500 years ago. Why morality good character of both individuals is an essential prerequisite of true friendship. College is a time of personal growth, and friendships have a tremendous impact on the development and experiences of an individual. It can bridge societal gaps of gender, race, social class, and differences in abilities. Any contribution, large or small, helps us produce intelligent, reflective radio that questions everything, including our most deeplyheld beliefs about science, morality, culture, and the human condition.
While even false friendships seem to bring benefits and ethical improvement amic. Types of friendships in aristotles nicomachean ethics books 8. Gay people in western europe from the beginning of the christian era to the fourteenth century university of chicago press, 1980. I was about six years old, and my mother, who considered herself somewhat of a. Its been argued that friendship is a greater gift than romantic love though its not uncommon for one to turn abruptly into the other, but whatever the case, friendship is certainly one of the most rewarding fruits of life from the sweetness of childhood friendships to the trickiness of workplace ones. Marcus tullius cicero was a poet, philosopher, humorist, and one of the greatest forensic orators rome ever produced. Aristotle and kant on selfdisclosure in friendship 227 moralia gives the most clear and concise treatment of the argument. The meaning of friendship an investigation of what it entails to be a friend among young men and women maryan yusuf bachelor thesis. Lorraine pangle argues that the difficulties surrounding this discussion are soon dispelled once one understands the purpose of the ethics as both a source of practical guidance for life and a profound, theoretical investigation into human. Philosophy and the art of friendship the history of. In any case, to have a perfect friend is like to have another self, since perfect friends make the same choices as each other. Pdf aristotle handout the three types of friendship. Treatises on friendship and old age by marcus tullius cicero translated by e.
Cheney departments of psychology and biology, university of pennsylvania, philadelphia, pennsylvania 19104. Going to college and then university i met a load of friends and i really likesd all of them it depresses the hell out of me when i realize all that all out paths had to diverge i miss them a great deal but it was better to have at least forged that bond if only. Bibliography includes bibliographical references p. Wartofsky, distinguished professor of philosophy, baruch college, city university of new york. Series 02 march 2019, nismed auditorium, up diliman dean ma. Download limit exceeded you have exceeded your daily download allowance.
This is a hard work to build friendship, find it and then save, not lose. This delicate dance has been examined by thinkers from aristotle to francis bacon. Some of the most noteworthy books contributing to a history of sexuality for our courses interests are. The contemplative life, on the other hand, even if it requires a community to nurture and train the wise before they have. For thoreau, friendship was one of lifes great rewards. Aristotle on friendship based on virtue nicomachean ethics book 8 philosophy core concepts duration. A read is counted each time someone views a publication summary such as the title, abstract, and list of authors, clicks on a figure, or views or downloads the fulltext. The contemplative life, on the other hand, even if it requires a community to nurture and. The connections she makes between nicomachean ethics and deanima, as well as her contrasts with homer, plato, and descartes are illuminating. The book gives central place to aristotles searching examination of friendship in the nicomachean ethics. But our life is too short and our power of vision too small for us to be more than friends in the sense of this sublime possibility. In 69 bc, he brought to order the corrupt sicilian governor verres. In poverty and other misfortunes of life, true friends are a sure refuge.
Although there are some people that might find pleasure in solitude, it seems clear than the majority of people do seek companionship if possible. Friendship with god chapter 1 i remember the first time that i decided i should be afraid of god. Philosophy and friendship edinburgh university press. One theologian, the twelfthcentury aelred of rievaulx, did write a dialogue on friendship somewhat in the spirit of ciceros. Lorraine smith pangle, aristotle and the philosophy of friendship. Friendship notes stanford encyclopedia of philosophy. In part, friedman s point is that sharing an evaluative perspective in the way that constitutes the intimacy of friendship involves coming to adopt her values as parts of my own sense of value. True friendship and true friends are what aristotle explains are mirrors to each other and a single soul dwelling in two bodies. Men, women, and sexual renunciation in early christianity.
The concept of having friends has been around for centuries. Pdf on feb 5, 2018, deeksha napa and others published aristotle on friendship find, read and cite all the research you need on researchgate. The features and effects of friendship in early adolescence. For some people, this is what makes life worthwhile, the. Their relationship is grounded in the emotion they feel at a given time or during a certain activity. Philosophy talk relies on the support of listeners like you to stay on the air and online. The features and effects of friendship in early adolescence thomas j. Let us then believe in our star friendship even if we should be compelled to be earth enemies. Emerson on the two pillars of friendship brain pickings. Friendship, he proposed, is at the very least a relationship of goodwill between individuals who reciprocate that goodwill. Cooper 1977a tries to refute this understanding of aristotle. This kind of relationship, he found, was more common among younger people. Okay, he didnt say it, exactly, but somebody said it on his behalf. Friendship and happiness from a philosophical perspective.
As such, friendship is undoubtedly central to our lives, in part because the special concern we have for our friends. Whiting 1991 argues that such an approach fails properly to make sense of the idea that i love my friend for her sake. We should not, he thinks, interpret the sense in which we wish our friends well because they are useful to us as providing a justification. Bemdt yde untverstty berndt, thomas j the features and effects of fnendshtp tn early adolescence chub development, 1982, 53, 14471460 early adolescent fnendships have often been assumed to be. Aristotles second kind of accidental friendship is based in pleasure. Friendship formation is a process of getting over selfishness, an ongoing effort to identify and overcome flaws caused by our imperfections. Research papers on aristotles view of friendship research papers on aristotles view of friendship is a topic of philosophy research papers. Friendship, as understood here, is a distinctively personal relationship that is grounded in a concern on the part of each friend for the welfare of the other, for the others sake, and that involves some degree of intimacy. These are the questions i explore in this talk on aristotles philosophy of friendship. Best quotes about friendship from the greatest thinkers. A principal fruit of friendship, francis bacon wrote in his timeless meditation on the subject, is the ease and discharge of the fulness and swellings of the heart, which passions of all kinds do cause and induce. What is the nature of its importance and value for human life. A philosophical and historical account of how great thinkers throughout time have grappled with what friendship means, both to society and the individual.
True to his belief that res publica the public affair was a citizens highest duty, he successfully defended a man prosecuted unjustly by a crony of the bloodthirsty dictator sulla. This is one of the three types of friendships that youre probably well aware of. We are curious about friendship because as social creatures. Aristotle and the philosophy of friendship read gov library of.
With the coming of the christian world, however, friendship fell into eclipse. Michael pakaluk has retrieved the thoughts of our greatest thinkers on the subject and collected them into a handsome and handy volume. Hello creeper friends if it only as easy as the show friends can be hard to manage its a give and take thing for sure. Translated by stanley lombardo aristotle, nicomachean ethics books viii and ix, rhetoric ii. Friendship, as understood here, is a distinctively personal. Any relationship, including friendship, we need to build, and build for a long time. Aristotle on love and friendship 210 about feelings but looks exclusively to intention,3 an intention which, moreover, has as its object the wellbeing of the other. Introductory note marcus tullius cicero, the greatest of roman orators and the chief master of latin prose style, was born at arpinum, jan. In the magna moralia, aristotle summarizes the argument as follows.
In order to classify friendship, aristotle differentiates between the objects of desire in life as a means to create a tripartite division. Think of your college friends or people who play in the same sports league. But later on, when you get pickier, more careful, and use the right filters, you start to realize that this kind of friendship is a doubleedged sword. The ideal of perfect friendship may strike the modern reader as being somewhat elitist, but aristotle is surely right in holding that the best kinds of friendship are both rare and demanding. However, as soon as he tried to expand it, the definition seemed to unravel. View philosophy of friendship research papers on academia. Attachment representations and characteristics of friendship relations during adolescence peter zimmermann department of experimental psychology, university of regensburg, regensburg 93040, germany received 2 june 2003. If, then, when one looked upon a friend one could see the nature and attributes of the friend. For aristotle, an act of friendship is undertaken both for the good of ones friend and for the good of oneself, and there is no reason to think that the one precludes the other. Squashed philosophers cicero friendship and old age.
Suzanne sterngillet addresses major and longstanding problems in aristotles treatment of friendship and suggests a plausible way of reconciling them. But in todays cultural landscape of muddled relationships scattered across various platforms for connecting. Kant on friendship 129 general evolves from the motive of the general love of mankind allgemeine menschenliebe to promote the happiness of others le collins 27. A cornerstone of the cursillo movement eduardo and his friends must have been inspired by the holy spirit, known as their foundational charism, to think of friendship as one of their fundamental ideas or factors that constitute or form the cursillo movement with its mission to become living witnesses to christ in the environments. It may seen odd but writers from paper masters have researched and found that aristotle takes much of his notion on friendship from politics. Treatises on friendship and old age, by marcus tullius cicero. A philosophical exploration of the meaning and significance of friendship. This is not an example of the work produced by our essay writing service. In addressing y this way, perhaps i have not yet said. In friendship the focus is always on the other, not the self. Is the identity of feeling, tastes, aims, viewsinterests.
226 891 3 180 256 469 436 795 1404 382 1178 58 277 445 341 117 1207 32 1276 1469 463 22 1357 560 299 155 158 1056 994 782 665 604 641 556 1260 531 167 24 370 413 747